Inferentialism, Representationalism and Derogatory Words
Author:
Daniel Whiting a
| Affiliation: | a University of Reading, UK |
DOI:
10.1080/09672550701383483
Publication Frequency:
5 issues per year
Published in:
International Journal of Philosophical Studies,
Volume
15,
Issue
2
June
2007
, pages 191
- 205
Subject:
Philosophy;
Formats available:
HTML
(English)
:
PDF
(English)
View Article:
View Article (PDF)
View Article (HTML)
Abstract
In a recent paper, after outlining various distinguishing features of derogatory words, Jennifer Hornsby suggests that the phenomenon raises serious difficulties for inferentialism. Against Hornsby, I claim that derogatory words do not pose any insuperable problems for inferentialism, so long as it is supplemented with apparatus borrowed from Grice and Hare. Moreover, I argue, derogatory expressions pose difficulties for Hornsby's favoured alternative theory of meaning, representationalism, unless it too is conjoined with a similar Grice/Hare mechanism. So, the upshot of the discussion is that, contra Hornsby, focus on derogatory expressions alone does not provide grounds for deciding between competing theories of meaning, but nevertheless serves to highlight important features that any such theory must acknowledge and incorporate.
|
| Keywords: inferentialism; representationalism; derogatory words; prescriptivism |
| view references (22) |

Download Citation
CiteULike
Del.icio.us
BibSonomy
Connotea